Achtung! Post unpopular music opinions that you have

[VoidTerraFirma]

ed has record sales of roughly 20M worldwide. he must be a musical genius.

Fixed.

 

[MonkeyZero]

Ooh, sunvalleylaw reminded me of another one: Hole is better than Nirvana

That's because Billy Corgan wrote and arranged most of their debut album. Duh.

 

[Bones McHorror]

That's because Billy Corgan wrote and arranged most of their debut album. Duh.

Fake news. Their debut didn't have Billy on it.

Celebrity Skin is their third album. And he only co-wrote 5/12 songs. And there are no songs he wrote or arranged singlehandedly.

 

[MonkeyZero]

Piano and horns in Jazz music is stupid. It should only ever be guitar, bass, and drums.
The Decendents are way more punk than The Ramones. Old punk is garbage.

 

[MonkeyZero]

Fake news. Their debut didn't have Billy on it.

Celebrity Skin is their third album. And he only co-wrote 5/12 songs. And there are no songs he wrote or arranged singlehandedly.

I stand partially corrected. I didn't know they had anything before Celebrity Skin because I think they suck and never pursued it.

 

[VoidTerraFirma]

I think Billy Corgan’s best work is Shout At The Devil.

 

[wok]

Jerry Cantrell > Kim Thayil

 

[yabba]

Piano and horns in Jazz music is stupid. It should only ever be guitar, bass, and drums.

No guitar in jazz ever!

 

[VoidTerraFirma]

Jerry Cantrell > Kim Thayil

By a wide, wide margin. We’re talking Pacific Ocean wide...and I’m a fan of Thayil.

 

[335clone]

Piano and horns in Jazz music is stupid. It should only ever be guitar, bass, and drums.

Miles would like a word with you out in the alley.

 

[Jbird]

Miles would like a word with you out in the alley.

David Sanborn & Kenny G made better jazz than Miles

 

[Help!I'maRock!]

 

[sunvalleylaw]

What's the deal with Batman? No super powers and a few tech gadgets?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

But so angsty.

 

[sunvalleylaw]

David Sanborn & Kenny G made better jazz than Miles

Oh wow. Now we are just trolling.

 

[Flamencology]

Oh wow. Now we are just trolling.

This thread wasn’t designed to account for the Jbirds of the world. The OP didn’t consider the individual whose every last musical opinion is not only justifiably unpopular, but also empirically wrong and disturbing.

It’s bullshit. These poor people don’t deserve to be dismissed as trolls just because they’re sick. They deserve not only our sympathy, but also corrective surgery.

 

[Help!I'maRock!]

This thread wasn’t designed to account for the Jbirds of the world. The OP didn’t consider the individual whose every last musical opinion is not only justifiably unpopular, but also empirically wrong and disturbing.

It’s bullshit. These poor people don’t deserve to be dismissed as trolls just because they’re sick. They deserve not only our sympathy, but also corrective surgery.

I would suggest euthanasia, but he’d just talk about Mr. Big in the 90s.

 

[Frank Prince]

John Mayer is always the worst guitar player in any multi-guitar situation he plays in, including his own bands and all those celebrity sit-ins he used to do where he forced himself on everyone from John Scofield to Keith Urban to Chris Botti.

Megadeth is edgier, more musical, and more lyrically savvy than Metallica.

Night Ranger was a great band with killer guitar players and singers who wrote both great rockers and great power ballads, no matter what a bunch of snooty people (who started out) at Harmony Central think.

 

[VoidTerraFirma]

I would suggest euthanasia, but he’d just talk about Mr. Big in the 90s.

Megadeth is edgier, more musical, and more lyrically savvy than Metallica.

 

[wok]

Discussing Metallica v Megadeth is moot because the best, most influential thrash band has always been Slayer

 

[VoidTerraFirma]

Dark Angel’s Darkness Descends is a better album than Slayer’s Reign In Blood.