Holiday Shopping: What Women Want, Men Don't Give

Modern Saint

Starve your Fear, Feed your Dream!
My wife loves Starbucks gift cards!

gifts_uni.jpg


When it comes to gifts, it's not the thought that counts. At least not in America's wealthiest households.


Two-thirds of affluent American women want gift cards. But less than a fifth of men will give it to them, according to a report from American Express Publishing and the Harrison Group out Thursday.


Instead, 70% of women are gifted clothing or jewelry.


A survey of 625 households that represent the top 10% of the nation's wage earners found a wide gap between what people want and what they will actually get.


Men should also lower their expectations. They want food and alcohol -- a third are hoping for gourmet foods and fine wine, and another third want gift cards. But women like to give none of those -- 30% are expected to give clothing, and another 15% books.


What wealthy shoppers are better suited for will be giving gifts to themselves.


Nearly half of women said they were extremely, or very likely, to buy themselves presents this holiday season. A third of men have similar intentions.


"Perhaps America is giving itself a bonus this year," said Jim Taylor, vice chairman of Harrison Group, in a statement.


Holiday retail sales are expected to increase 4.1% this year, according to estimates from the National Retail Federation. That's the most optimistic forecast from the group since the recession.


The American Express and Harrison Group survey found that gift giving will be down overall this year, but the top 10% will spend nearly 22% more on gifts this year than they did in 2011.

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/holiday-shopping-women-want-men-153800266.html
 
I'm not falling for that. Nothing says, "I couldn't be bothered to spend more than two minutes thinking about what you want," like a gift card. My wife would skin me alive if I did that.

The American Express and Harrison Group survey found that gift giving will be down overall this year, but the top 10% will spend nearly 22% more on gifts this year than they did in 2011.

Oh goodie for them.
 
We usually end up not getting each other anything. She asks me what I want and I say "nothing", which is true; I really dislike other people buying clothes for me, and a gift card generally means compromising on something you don't really want but that's all they got for sale. Since I asked for nothing, my wife feels bad requesting something, so I'm usually pinned with the "birthday/xmas mr killjoy" title each year. Small price to pay for less crap in the house I guess.
 
We really don't want anything this year (or last).
We are trying to figure out some sort of "thing to do" or "place to go" in which we can include all of the kids as well.
We're coming up short on good ideas that we can afford.
 
I've been getting gift cards for Mrs D for years. She is hard to fit and picky about clothing, and neither of us are very big on jewelry.

My birthday/Fathers Day/Christmas gift every year is me going to Pragestock so I ask for no gifts. I have more stuff than I need anyways.
 
I haven't had to buy a Christmas present for a girlfriend in about 5 years. That is both awesome and incredibly sucky.
 
My wife wouldn't like a gift card from me, as she likes my tastes as a shopper and would prefer to open presents. She definitely would prefer gift cards from other family members though. I think that's a much better present for someone that you're not married to.

I keep trying to talk her into the idea of a really nice dinner, or a vacation, instead of presents. I'll never win that one. Girl likes her presents.
 
Giving a great gift is easy. Buy them something they want, but probably wouldn't buy for themselves. It's simple and effective.
 
I think I really lucked out with my wife. We both hate giving gifts, so we never exchange them. Well not entirely true, I got her a bar of dark chocolate for our anniversary and she got me a big box of Mike and Ikes.
 
Back
Top