Time to thin the herd?

What to sell?

  • Fender 2009 MIM telecaster

    Votes: 2 10.5%
  • Fender 2017 Duo-Sonic

    Votes: 6 31.6%
  • Gibson 2012 Les Paul Junior Special P90

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • Godin 40th (2012?) Anniversary Acousticaster

    Votes: 6 31.6%
  • Guild 2016 Starfire IV

    Votes: 1 5.3%
  • Gibson 2015 Les Paul Double Cutaway P90

    Votes: 8 42.1%
  • Fender 2014 FSR Blacktop Jazzmaster HH

    Votes: 14 73.7%

  • Total voters
    19

bsman

b00b
I find myself playing acoustic about 90% of the time these days, and after cleaning and setting up my music room have decided that I really don't need all of these guitars I have hanging around. Therefore, I am seriously considering selling as few as one and perhaps as many as three of the electrics I have and was curious to see the response from this group. You can vote up to three off the island. Chances are, I will likely be getting another carbon fiber acoustic in the not-too-distant future, so I really need the stand space. I love them all (although, not equally) but really just don't have room for a bunch of guitars that are collecting dust at the moment.
 
It's hard to say without knowing the full make up of the herd, unless this list comprises your whole collection...

Do any guitars listed duplicate others?
 
MIM tele is ultra replaceable. MIM Blacktop JM is a pretty meh guitar...I, like everyone, owned one or the other of these BT JMs at some point. It’s fine, but it’s not really a JM and bolt on HH guitars are easy to come by.

And I voted the 2015 Gibby off because I’m assuming you probably bought it bc it was on blowout.

All of these will be relatively easy to sell provided they’re not beat to shit.
 
The tele is close to my heart, because it has a lovely set of Alnico III Mojotone pickups in it (and if I could get it to work properly, an Emerson 4-way kit), but I rather agree with you on the other too. At this point, I think it most likely that the JM and LPDC would head off into the sunset. I don't really dislike the LP, but it doesn't really give me anything I don't already have, and it's mint, so I could likely get what I paid for it ($579)
 
The tele is close to my heart, because it has a lovely set of Alnico III Mojotone pickups in it (and if I could get it to work properly, an Emerson 4-way kit), but I rather agree with you on the other too. At this point, I think it most likely that the JM and LPDC would head off into the sunset. I don't really dislike the LP, but it doesn't really give me anything I don't already have, and it's mint, so I could likely get what I paid for it ($579)

That makes sense. If the Tele is doing it’s job (being awesome) it’s worth keeping because you can always use it. I would hold on to the duo sonic even though there’s some tonal overlap...I think these MIM Duo Sonics are real gems. I wouldn’t be surprised if they become cult classics after they’re discontinued in a few years.
 
That makes sense. If the Tele is doing it’s job (being awesome) it’s worth keeping because you can always use it. I would hold on to the duo sonic even though there’s some tonal overlap...I think these MIM Duo Sonics are real gems. I wouldn’t be surprised if they become cult classics after they’re discontinued in a few years.

Once I got the action dialed in on the tele, it has never wavered an inch. It has been 100% reliable - except the time I broke a string during a show - and also has the most hand-filling profile of any of my electrics. My only issue with it (at least, if I could figure out how to get the @)#$^#^ wiring right - my four-way switch currently only gives me two tones, although they are to die for) is that it is also the heaviest electric I have.
 
JM and the DCLP seem like reasonable choices to let go.
I wouldn’t have much use for the Godin either if I also had a proper acoustic guitar.
 
I loved the sound and feel of my 2015 LP DC but the thing had constant tuning and intonation problems, even after I changed the tuners and nut.

I sold it locally as is and only lost $40 on the tuners. It was up on CL two days later for $175 more than I sold it for.

I’d make a list of features that your top 3 guitars have/do, sell off several and buy one really nice guitar that covers the ground you want to cover.
 
Last edited:
Time to stop calling your guitar collection a herd. They're guitars, not cows. You're a musician, not a rancher.
 
Time to stop calling your guitar collection a herd. They're guitars, not cows. You're a musician, not a rancher.

Their favorite album is...
pink-floyd-atom-cow-cover_1.jpg
 
You should send me the Duo-Sonic for aqwhile, just to see if you miss it. If you don't, we can work something out... :wink:
 
Since 3 of the responses mention the "Junior, " I should point out that that guitar is not a Junior, but a Les Paul Special singlecut. One of Gibson's exclusive "Misnomer Line" (tm).

I have the same guitar and refuse to use Gibson's ridiculous and oxymoronic "Jr. Special" name for exactly this reason. Thank goodness it just has "Special" on the actual guitar.
 
Since 3 of the responses mention the "Junior, " I should point out that that guitar is not a Junior, but a Les Paul Special singlecut. One of Gibson's exclusive "Misnomer Line" (tm).

I have the same guitar and refuse to use Gibson's ridiculous and oxymoronic "Jr. Special" name for exactly this reason. Thank goodness it just has "Special" on the actual guitar.
Would I be right in assuming that's one of the last ones you'd thin from the herd? :)
 
Back
Top