Thoughts?

A Custom Shop Les Paul Standard exhibits the finest in materials, construction and historical accuracy, making it one of the best sounding and playing electric guitars on the planet.

So a standard Les Paul is built with so so materials, marginal construction, and historicalish accuracy?
 
This is only good if you have an overdrive pedal with a guitar built into it.

Seriously, make a guitar a guitar and a pedal a pedal. I agree with the others that Gibson should stop all this stupid shit and just concentrate on making really good guitars and trying to make them affordable. And by "affordable" I don't mean everything they make has to ring in at under $200. I don't think it's unreasonable to price a nice LP in the $2,500 to $3k range and expect a fuckin' killer guitar. It just seems to me that these idiots are going down a road that will make it difficult for them to recover their credibility from. In the meantime they're turning an iconic instrument brand into a laughing stock.

This is symptom, if not the direct result, of the MBA boom of late 1980s through the 1990s.

I'm not saying business education is bad OR that getting a masters degree in business administration is the root of the problems of companies like Gibson. But not unlike the MLS i hold and several other graduate level degrees, they can be (possibly tend to be) less useful as individual degrees. Now, combine your MBA and experience in the professional business world with at last a BA/BS in engineering, design, music, etc. (or even more ideal another masters in one of those areas) and you're in a much better position to be hired as a middle manager to CEO of a company like Gibson.

Applying basic/general ("standardized") business skills and knowledge to every type of business will not work. Norlin and Fender almost destroyed the reputations of Gibson and Fender, until the men and women of those companies got together and changed the business. Particularly Fender had an in house team buy the company from CBS so the experts could get back to the business of Fender making and selling great guitars, basses, amps, strings, and more.

Henry, however, seems to be an exception to the rule...at least for the last 20 or so years. He's and engineer that has a MBA. When he bought Gibson in 1986, he got them back on track in a manner similar to Schultz's buyout of Fender. They went back to making great instruments in the manner of their classic guitars. Now both companies are buying into the whole lifestyle brand shit that pervades so much of the business world in regards to long standing/well established companies. This speaks to the Tim & Pete Guitar Show clip:



There's only so many people that can or will play guitar and only so many of them are going to buy more than one guitar. We are making more than will ever be played and charging far more for many than they are worth, regardless of who is building them and where. Decent guitars aren't disposable, so you don't need to build another LP to replace every one that's already been sold. But the basic model of business as taught in 99% of the MBA programs is about making more and more product to make more and more money. So the corporate greed model has little future in the world of guitar manufacture...although they are really trying to change that.

Wow...nice rambling buddy! Yeah, thanks, chum.
 
But the basic model of business as taught in 99% of the MBA programs is about making more and more product to make more and more money. So the corporate greed model has little future in the world of guitar manufacture...although they are really trying to change that.

Wow...nice rambling buddy! Yeah, thanks, chum.

I take unbridgeable with the term "corporate greed" but putting that aside what would you have them do?

I understand what your are trying to say, but at the end of the day they are in the business of building/selling guitars. If they don't, they can't keep the doors open. As most are aware I have very good friends in the guitar business, and I am aware of the difficulties they face. Granted they can do their own thing and Gibson/Fender are more limited in what they can do.

What they choose to do to sell guitars seems pretty dumb to most of us, I would say we probably are not their target market anyway. Without access to their numbers I have no idea how their strategy is working, but I at least give them credit for trying something different than an endless string of reissues, relics, signature models, and junk entry level stuff.

At the end of the day they have to sell more and more guitars to stay in business. Your costs only go up year to year so if you don't sell more you will eventually be out of business. It's not greed it's staying in business.
 
I take unbridgeable with the term "corporate greed" but putting that aside what would you have them do?

I understand what your are trying to say, but at the end of the day they are in the business of building/selling guitars. If they don't, they can't keep the doors open. As most are aware I have very good friends in the guitar business, and I am aware of the difficulties they face. Granted they can do their own thing and Gibson/Fender are more limited in what they can do.

What they choose to do to sell guitars seems pretty dumb to most of us, I would say we probably are not their target market anyway. Without access to their numbers I have no idea how their strategy is working, but I at least give them credit for trying something different than an endless string of reissues, relics, signature models, and junk entry level stuff.

At the end of the day they have to sell more and more guitars to stay in business. Your costs only go up year to year so if you don't sell more you will eventually be out of business. It's not greed it's staying in business.

The only reason to sell 'more and more' guitars is to appease the board and stockholders who insist that every quarter shows increased revenue/dividends. Otherwise why can't you have a stable business model with a certain profit margin? Every year you can adjust the new model year pricing to correspond with any increase in operational costs. If the consumers find your product superior to your competitors, then you see a resulting profit increase based on increased sales, but someone has to lose along the way. That's how business used to work. The idea that every guitar manufacturer can sell more guitars this year than last year is ludicrous, at least as a long term strategy.
 
I take unbridgeable with the term "corporate greed" but putting that aside what would you have them do?

I understand what your are trying to say, but at the end of the day they are in the business of building/selling guitars. If they don't, they can't keep the doors open. As most are aware I have very good friends in the guitar business, and I am aware of the difficulties they face. Granted they can do their own thing and Gibson/Fender are more limited in what they can do.

What they choose to do to sell guitars seems pretty dumb to most of us, I would say we probably are not their target market anyway. Without access to their numbers I have no idea how their strategy is working, but I at least give them credit for trying something different than an endless string of reissues, relics, signature models, and junk entry level stuff.

At the end of the day they have to sell more and more guitars to stay in business. Your costs only go up year to year so if you don't sell more you will eventually be out of business. It's not greed it's staying in business.

But I think the problem in this case is Gibson's present "economy of scale" and how that is perceived and pursued in today's business world. They started out at a certain size and grew to meet demand. But then they got too big. And the business 101 philosophy to keep a bigger company going is to get bigger and sell more. But as was pointed out guitars are not as disposable as other products and only so many people are gonna buy 'em. So, you CAN'T get bigger and sell more because the demand just isn't there. How big are some of the other companies that are selling great guitars? Collings, Eastwood, etc.? Not as big as Gibson. But the scale of their operation is appropriate for the demand. Gibson would need to close up, be sold in a fire sale and be reborn at a more appropriate (smaller) size. Very traumatic but that might be the only way to get back on track.
 
Btw, what the hell is "Hide Glue Fit"? As opposed to "Expose Glue Fit"? :facepalm:

Just throw some random words on a screen and call it a feature?
 
A Custom Shop Les Paul Standard exhibits the finest in materials, construction and historical accuracy, making it one of the best sounding and playing electric guitars on the planet.

So a standard Les Paul is built with so so materials, marginal construction, and historicalish accuracy?

Yes.
 
Btw, what the hell is "Hide Glue Fit"? As opposed to "Expose Glue Fit"? :facepalm:

Just throw some random words on a screen and call it a feature?

41choscI7hL._SL500_AC_SS350_.jpg
 
This makes perfect sense from the Gibson perspective. Drop a $20 component into a, what, $2,000 guitar and up the asking price by 3 or 4 figures.
 
I take unbridgeable with the term "corporate greed" but putting that aside what would you have them do?

I understand what your are trying to say, but at the end of the day they are in the business of building/selling guitars. If they don't, they can't keep the doors open. As most are aware I have very good friends in the guitar business, and I am aware of the difficulties they face. Granted they can do their own thing and Gibson/Fender are more limited in what they can do.

What they choose to do to sell guitars seems pretty dumb to most of us, I would say we probably are not their target market anyway. Without access to their numbers I have no idea how their strategy is working, but I at least give them credit for trying something different than an endless string of reissues, relics, signature models, and junk entry level stuff.

At the end of the day they have to sell more and more guitars to stay in business. Your costs only go up year to year so if you don't sell more you will eventually be out of business. It's not greed it's staying in business.

Corporate greed isn't about profit and growth in the traditional sense. I'm talking about the model wherein a company makes say $100 million a year in profit for fiscal 2016, after everyone and everything is paid. So for Gibson we'll say:
  • employees
    • management
    • design
    • manufacturing
    • inspection/set-up
    • delivery (in-house or outsourced)
    • marketing/advertising (again in-house of contracted)
    • sales
    • HR
    • facilities/maintenance
  • related benefits
  • and any other costs directly incurred in the process of developing, making, and selling Gibson products
The earnings projections for the next year are almost always going to increase. As such they'll expect to make $120 million in profit for fiscal 2017. So, if they only make another $100 million, they've failed. If a company like Gibson only makes $80 million in profit, heads will role and likely other jobs are lost. The company hasn't "lost" anything, they've just not achieved the same level of profit/success as the previous year. You can't maintain a level of profitability, CEOs (beholden to BoDs and shareholders) need to see increased profits annually, and not just above inflation rates>

This is the foundation of the concept of corporate greed. It's part of the reason they don't want to pay for employee healthcare (or other benefits), they outsource work, underpay and overwork everyone from middle management on down, don't want to be taxed, aren't generally interested in following environmental laws, and more. Anything that gets in the way of making money.

I wrote a bunch of other stuff, but it's not particularly relevant to the notion of corporate greed...so I'm done. :thu:
 
Corporate greed isn't about profit and growth in the traditional sense. I'm talking about the model wherein a company makes say $100 million a year in profit for fiscal 2016, after everyone and everything is paid. So for Gibson we'll say:
  • employees
    • management
    • design
    • manufacturing
    • inspection/set-up
    • delivery (in-house or outsourced)
    • marketing/advertising (again in-house of contracted)
    • sales
    • HR
    • facilities/maintenance
  • related benefits
  • and any other costs directly incurred in the process of developing, making, and selling Gibson products
The earnings projections for the next year are almost always going to increase. As such they'll expect to make $120 million in profit for fiscal 2017. So, if they only make another $100 million, they've failed. If a company like Gibson only makes $80 million in profit, heads will role and likely other jobs are lost. The company hasn't "lost" anything, they've just not achieved the same level of profit/success as the previous year. You can't maintain a level of profitability, CEOs (beholden to BoDs and shareholders) need to see increased profits annually, and not just above inflation rates>

This is the foundation of the concept of corporate greed. It's part of the reason they don't want to pay for employee healthcare (or other benefits), they outsource work, underpay and overwork everyone from middle management on down, don't want to be taxed, aren't generally interested in following environmental laws, and more. Anything that gets in the way of making money.

I wrote a bunch of other stuff, but it's not particularly relevant to the notion of corporate greed...so I'm done. :thu:


We will agree to disagree. The reason to go into business is to make money, not employee people, pay taxes to anything else on your list. If employees feel over worked and/or underpaid they should look for employment elsewhere. You have no obligation to provide heath care to employees. It was started as a extra benefit to employees but is in no way a right. You know when you're hired if you will be offered heath care. If they don't offer it go somewhere else. Outsourcing is not a bad thing it reduces cost, increases efficiency and and in most cases keeps you competitive. It is your obligation as a corporate officer to pay as little in tax as possible. It's wasted capital, and if you aren't working to reduce you tax burden in any and every way possible you should be fired immediately. If a goal is set at $100 million and you only reach $80 you should be held accountable and make changes as necessary.
 
Very different yet very legit reasons presented here as to why I'd never buy either a Gibson or a Reverend.
 
Another example of Gibson solving problems for guitar player that the were unaware they had.

Why not instead raise employee morale, stop micromanaging, and improve quality of the product.
Pretty much what the majority of the comments on the OP page said, and I totally agree.
 
We will agree to disagree. The reason to go into business is to make money, not employee people, pay taxes to anything else on your list. If employees feel over worked and/or underpaid they should look for employment elsewhere. You have no obligation to provide heath care to employees. It was started as a extra benefit to employees but is in no way a right. You know when you're hired if you will be offered heath care. If they don't offer it go somewhere else. Outsourcing is not a bad thing it reduces cost, increases efficiency and and in most cases keeps you competitive. It is your obligation as a corporate officer to pay as little in tax as possible. It's wasted capital, and if you aren't working to reduce you tax burden in any and every way possible you should be fired immediately. If a goal is set at $100 million and you only reach $80 you should be held accountable and make changes as necessary.

Outsourcing is a horrendously bad thing for any company, and is why any and everything the company I work for can do in house, we do in house. The QC issues alone are reason enough to keep things in house. I have made engineering changes on parts at companies that outsource those parts, and it takes weeks to get modified parts in house, you have to deal with existing inventory, and often the change you wanted is done incorrectly. That doesn't even account for the lost jobs caused by a bean counter looking to appease the board/investors. Anyone who believes that outsourcing improves efficiency needs to remove their tie and actually DO something.

But what do I know? I just make space flight hardware in an agile aerospace company that is making a very nice profit margin while undercutting old school aerospace companies and paying their employees well above the median income for this area, as well as providing the best benefits I have had since 1984. We are obviously doing everything wrong.thwap0
 
Ok,why the Reverend hate?
Are they aligned with Gibby?

Unrelated. I'm a fan of Reverend in theory. I only say that because I've yet to get a chance to play any of their instruments.

I like a lot of what they're doing and have done. Joe seems to have a lot of great ideas. Ken seems to passionate about the product and does a good job promoting them. They make what seems like a great product at a good price. You're not overpaying for past glory, where that aging of the exact plastic used for the truss rod cover is sold as important (and sadly perceived as important by a certain percentage of their patrons).
 
Unrelated. I'm a fan of Reverend in theory. I only say that because I've yet to get a chance to play any of their instruments.

I like a lot of what they're doing and have done. Joe seems to have a lot of great ideas. Ken seems to passionate about the product and does a good job promoting them. They make what seems like a great product at a good price. You're not overpaying for past glory, where that aging of the exact plastic used for the truss rod cover is sold as important (and sadly perceived as important by a certain percentage of their patrons).
I have liked a few Revs,but never pulled the trigger. My playing is better suited to lower end guitars.
I have an Affinity Tele on it's way today.
I do have my eye on a Godin though.
 
Outsourcing is a horrendously bad thing for any company, and is why any and everything the company I work for can do in house, we do in house. The QC issues alone are reason enough to keep things in house. I have made engineering changes on parts at companies that outsource those parts, and it takes weeks to get modified parts in house, you have to deal with existing inventory, and often the change you wanted is done incorrectly. That doesn't even account for the lost jobs caused by a bean counter looking to appease the board/investors. Anyone who believes that outsourcing improves efficiency needs to remove their tie and actually DO something.

But what do I know? I just make space flight hardware in an agile aerospace company that is making a very nice profit margin while undercutting old school aerospace companies and paying their employees well above the median income for this area, as well as providing the best benefits I have had since 1984. We are obviously doing everything wrong.thwap0

Yeah, we all have different perspectives and experiences. I'd rather pay extra for a guitar built in North America rather than Asia, as long as the quality is equal or better. The global economy isn't really serving the globe at this point in time...only the global 1%. I like Godin and Hecho en Mexico Fender stuff for this reason...and even the latter you're paying extra for the name, but despite that, it's some of the best bang for the buck Fender stuff available. Some of better than the US stuff, but for less cash. And even then it's still Fender outsourcing...it's hard to win.
 
Outsourcing is a horrendously bad thing for any company, and is why any and everything the company I work for can do in house, we do in house. The QC issues alone are reason enough to keep things in house. I have made engineering changes on parts at companies that outsource those parts, and it takes weeks to get modified parts in house, you have to deal with existing inventory, and often the change you wanted is done incorrectly. That doesn't even account for the lost jobs caused by a bean counter looking to appease the board/investors. Anyone who believes that outsourcing improves efficiency needs to remove their tie and actually DO something.

But what do I know? I just make space flight hardware in an agile aerospace company that is making a very nice profit margin while undercutting old school aerospace companies and paying their employees well above the median income for this area, as well as providing the best benefits I have had since 1984. We are obviously doing everything wrong.thwap0

Of course there are alway exceptions. There are many products that need to be made that can not, or should not be outsourced. That being said many products can be made more efficiently and at lower cost when outsourced. Outsource also does not necessarily mean overseas either.

I'm in the water treatment business. I sell patented products to a specialized industry. I outsource the manufacturing and shipping of my products to a company in Chicago that makes equipment for many of the largest water treatment company in the world. They have manufacturing, engineering, and logistical abilities far beyond my own. It makes much more sense to outsource to them and allow me to concentrate in my area of expertise than it does for me to try to do it all myself.

As far as job loss is concerned, if I do everything myself at higher cost and lower quality more jobs would be lost than the handful of machinists, assemblers and laborers I would need to do the job on my own.
 
Back
Top