Politics.

It's easy to get to the point where you no longer want to interact with people of opposing views. The art of civil discourse is dead. The notion of compromise is being deteriorated daily and replaced by stubborn and unyielding extremism. The vitriol and disdain has reached a boiling point. It's no longer "we the people", it's "us and them". And while the division grows wider, the power holders fill the vacuum in between which just gives them more power. We're a nation of a hugely apathetic percentage in population, and one of finger pointers blaming each other in complete ignorance of what is going on in the halls of government.

It's pretty hard to engage in any sort of political conversation when the other person just wants to talk out of their ass with no interest in diplomacy or opposition.

It's a clusterfuck out there.

This is why we can't have nice things.

It's also pretty difficult to discuss things with some people because there seems to be a tendency to not discern between facts and opinions anymore. Not every 'opinion' is right, yet you get these crazy arguments where people keep insisting a fact is just 'your opinion' and they are free to have 'their opinion'. I mean, if you take a 100kg weight, you can make a very convincing argument for it being 110kg and that being their opinion therefore somehow valid, but the damn weight is still 100 kg, it doesn't change because you argue otherwise... The fact that I think the weight is 100 kg doesn't have anything to do with me wanting the weight to be 100kg or it being my opinion, it's just that it is fact that is not changed until the weight it modified. I have a hard time getting this into some peoples heads lately.
 
Last edited:
MV5BMTk4NDYyNTU3Nl5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNjE4NTQ0MQ@@._V1._CR11,6,327,487_SX214_AL_.jpg
See... As an outsider of the U.S. ... Many, many, many of us don't see the problem as it being a standstill between two extremes. We see it as a standstill between extremists and centrists. The other end of the scale is practically empty, as represented by government, from the perspective of other developed countries.
Interesting. I was thinking during exercise today of where I stand. All I can come up with is that it really depends on the issue. Not sure if that makes me moderate or centrist or more independent. I suppose in relation to your post, it would be more centrist. To me it often gets back to becoming informed on the best way to handle an issue such as health care or environment or the economy. As opposed to issues of what and whose rights are protected under the Constitution. Those sorts of discussions tend to need a different approach and analysis.
 
Interesting. I was thinking during exercise today of where I stand. All I can come up with is that it really depends on the issue. Not sure if that makes me moderate or centrist or more independent. I suppose in relation to your post, it would be more centrist. To me it often gets back to becoming informed on the best way to handle an issue such as health care or environment or the economy. As opposed to issues of what and whose rights are protected under the Constitution. Those sorts of discussions tend to need a different approach and analysis.

Yup, the constitution is a 200 year old piece of paper, what was a good idea back then is not necessarily a good idea right now. Just clinging to and going to court waving the constitution just because you disagree seems like a very unproductive way of getting on with a country and is especially harmful for getting along in a country.
 
Yup, the constitution is a 200 year old piece of paper, what was a good idea back then is not necessarily a good idea right now. Just clinging to and going to court waving the constitution just because you disagree seems like a very unproductive way of getting on with a country and is especially harmful for getting along in a country.

Yeah. Give it lots of credit for being one of the first of its kind, and for the participation of some pretty brilliant people.

But it also included the participation of lots of dumb scumbag motherfuckers, too. Thus slavery, and hence the Civil War, to cite the most extreme example.

Like many 1.0 versions, it's archaic. Most people wouldn't choose MS-DOS as their primary OS.

It makes legislative progress incredibly difficult, to the detriment of the nation, again and again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
well, I cannot really respond because it might start to get into the politics thing. But the whole idea of a constitution is that there are rights that are guaranteed that cannot be abridged by law. I think that is a good thing. But certainly what rights and whose has been an evolving concept. When the document was written, slavery was legal and slaves were considered property. Certainly things have evolved. But the core principles remain at least a good skeletal frame work in most cases, I believe.
 
well, I cannot really respond because it might start to get into the politics thing. But the whole idea of a constitution is that there are rights that are guaranteed that cannot be abridged by law. I think that is a good thing. But certainly what rights and whose has been an evolving concept. When the document was written, slavery was legal and slaves were considered property. Certainly things have evolved. But the core principles remain at least a good skeletal frame work in most cases, I believe.

You could say the same thing of any first-world democracy. The US is not unique in having a constitution, nor is it unique in having legislation that protects individual rights and freedoms.

Like I said, the US deserves credit for articulating and legislating that. But these things benefit from evolution.
 
See... As an outsider of the U.S. ... Many, many, many of us don't see the problem as it being a standstill between two extremes. We see it as a standstill between extremists and centrists. The other end of the scale is practically empty, as represented by government, from the perspective of other developed countries.
Some of us within the US recognize this as well. There is no "Left" in national US politics (with the exception of Bernie Sanders).
 
There is the quote I was looking for. Rachel Maddow on inalienable rights. Paraphrased, "Inalienable or minority rights are not subject to vote. That is why you call them rights."


Now powers of congress vs. the executive and etc. is a whole different area of constitutional law, separate from individual rights. Sometimes the old document works there, sometimes it does not. And certainly that area of law has evolved as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
The US is not unique in having a constitution, nor is it unique in having legislation that protects individual rights and freedoms.
no. certainly not. Not even completely original as the Magna Carta preceded it. And the document must evolve which is the primary purpose of SCOTUS. I am pretty sure it would very tough to rewrite the code to version 2.0 in this country. Interpretation is what we are left with. Or I suppose war. Not too keen on that idea. Just glad SCOTUS ruled as it did this week, and that some progress in other areas not before SCOTUS seems to be happening.
 
I am pretty sure it would very tough to rewrite the code to version 2.0 in this country. .

i think the real problem would be .......who the HELL would you trust to rewrite it......TODAY??

i don't know anyone in "power" that i would trust to write their own name, let alone the new constitution. it would be completely one sided. and if you tried to do it by committee......you'd end up exactly where we are in congress right now......NO WHERE.

i'd very much rather leave it the way it is and nearly unmodifiable. it's just safer that way for everyone. IMHO
 
no. certainly not. Not even completely original as the Magna Carta preceded it. And the document must evolve which is the primary purpose of SCOTUS. I am pretty sure it would very tough to rewrite the code to version 2.0 in this country. Interpretation is what we are left with. Or I suppose war. Not too keen on that idea. Just glad SCOTUS ruled as it did this week, and that some progress in other areas not before SCOTUS seems to be happening.

No, I agree with that.

But far too many believe in it being a sacred document, one sent down from Mount Sinai.

"That's not what the Founding Fathers had in mind..." is not a legitimate argument. Nor is it a view that the smarter/wiser ones would have endorsed.

You don't need to write a new constitution to make some changes; easier to pass legislation, removing the filibuster, instant runoff voting, popular vote presidential elections, more aggressive anti-gerrymandering legislation, etcetera.
 
No, I agree with that.

But far too many believe in it being a sacred document, one sent down from Mount Sinai.

"That's not what the Founding Fathers had in mind..." is not a legitimate argument. Nor is it a view that the smarter/wiser ones would have endorsed.
Agreed. It is an evolving document. It has been and continues to be. It is not some law sent down from Landru enforced by hooded figures with sparkle tubes.

I also agree with @mongooz that there are not too many I would trust on a re-write. And a full re-write would never happen anyway. It would have to be individual amendment process. pretty tough sledding.
 
well, I cannot really respond because it might start to get into the politics thing. But the whole idea of a constitution is that there are rights that are guaranteed that cannot be abridged by law. I think that is a good thing. But certainly what rights and whose has been an evolving concept. When the document was written, slavery was legal and slaves were considered property. Certainly things have evolved. But the core principles remain at least a good skeletal frame work in most cases, I believe.

I'm not saying the whole thing should be thrown out, but it's pretty odd to keep sticking to a set of constitutional rules that were written down in what was basically another world. For example, the Netherlands have had constitutions since 1798, but it was modified several times and had a complete redo in 1983 to adjust all articles to current times as well as some scrapped articles and some added articles. That, complemented by the fact that it's not being used as a political weapon, makes it a much more valuable tool for government than what seems to be currently happening in US politics. Base ideas like human rights etc should always be in there, but that doesn't mean it should be some untouchable thing when it's causing stagnation.

Hell, if we'd be sticking with and enforcing the old constitution Catholics would be prohibited to hold processions :embarrassed:
 
[QUOTE="ColourofFire, post: 1162536, member: 308"For example, the Netherlands have had constitutions since 1798, but it was modified several times and had a complete redo in 1983 to adjust all articles to current times as well as some scrapped articles and some added articles. That, complemented by the fact that it's not being used as a political weapon, makes it a much more valuable tool for government than what seems to be currently happening in US politics. Base ideas like human rights etc should always be in there, but that doesn't mean it should be some untouchable thing when it's causing stagnation.
[/QUOTE]

That could be very nice. Just really hard to pull off over here, it would seem.
 
[/QUOTE]That could be very nice. Just really hard to pull off over here, it would seem.[/QUOTE]

well, i think that big corp owning most of our representatives has a little to do with why nothing good can get done. just sayin'
 
Back
Top