Discuss

Ok you guys have incensed me and I'm gonna tear you a new one.

CONDUCTIN

Its a mind fuck the likes of which you have never seen. Why?
You have to be in three places at once...wtf you say?

1. You must be in the future. You are LEADING the band. Your gestures have to be ahead of the music. You have to have the music playing in your head a moment before the orchestra plays it.
2. You must be in the NOW. You have to listen in the present and hear the actual sound of the band.
3. You must be in the past. You have to be critical of what you have heard. You have to decide, "OK, I just heard the music. Did it sound the way I wanted it too? Did my gestures convey what I want the band to do?" If yes, flow on bro. If not, you have to correct your gestures and feed forward that info into the future so the band can correct itself with your next gesture.

Try doing that circle for just two minutes and you will have a new appreciation for those snobs in the patent leather shoes that can keep it up for two hours.

That's just the beginning Skynard fans!

Now you have to deal with 101 first class assholes called "musicians". A conductor has to have a SERIOUSLY ALPHA personality to make it all work. He has to be able to kneecap that jerk with a glance. But you can't beat a great performance out of anyone. He has to inspire! He has to make the band WANT to play the Nutcracker for the 50 billionth time. He also has to have advanced working knowledge of every instrument in the band. Do you know how many different mallets the tympani guy has? Do you know what they sound like? Do you know how many written ways there are to attack violin strings? (There are about 13 or 14 if I remember.) Do you know what THEY sound like? ETC for every other instrument. You better know how to conduct in an historically correct manner unless you want to be laughed off the stage too. Music history is a must. Try cracking a book on music history and history in general for that matter. Learn what political and social environment these great composers operated in. Learn who their contemporaries were in other artistic fields. What have you got to lose? You can tivo the NASCAR and you will have more insight into MUSIC than that guy at the end of the bar who keeps raising his Miller and mumbling there will never be another Stevie Ray.

Seriously, I encourage you to go out and buy a pocket score of some music you like. They are cheap. Buy the CD. Learn the simple gestures to beat time, dynamics, syncopation and give cues. Conduct the music in the quiet of your own living room. Don't worry...no-one has to see. It WILL make you a better musician. You will be astounded at your musical progress in areas that you think are completely unrelated. When you can successfully conduct a piece its a feeling like no other. You think you understand music? You think you are 'one' with music?

li3lZhZh.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yes, that’s all good but if the musicians are reading their sheet music they aren’t looking at the conductor....so we are back to what’s the point of a conductor?
 
I've never conducted, but I played in a orchestra for years - the musicians are not just looking at the sheet music, they're also looking at the conductor, because he/she is conveying information that's not in the sheet music
 
Noted Belgian daredevil Tom Waes did an episode on conducting. It was a pretty tough gig, even if he does always say that.

 
Also, if the orchestra has played the Nutcracker 50 billion times, shouldn’t they have memorized it? I mean c’mon. I can play a cover band gig and play 40 songs and don’t need paper to show me how to play it. You would think with all the Ritalin use/abuse going on these musicians could memorize some music that’s hundreds of years old by now.
 
I've never conducted, but I played in a orchestra for years - the musicians are not just looking at the sheet music, they're also looking at the conductor, because he/she is conveying information that's not in the sheet music
Like what?
 
Also, if the orchestra has played the Nutcracker 50 billion times, shouldn’t they have memorized it? I mean c’mon. I can play a cover band gig and play 40 songs and don’t need paper to show me how to play it. You would think with all the Ritalin use/abuse going on these musicians could memorize some music that’s hundreds of years old by now.
they have basically memorized it; it's not like they're sight reading. The music is there as a reminder, which is helpful because the "songs" they're playing are a lot longer than any of those 40 cover songs.
Like what?
tempo (which is rarely static), volume and timbre dynamics, etc. The sheet music gives general info, but that general info can be interpreted in lots of different ways. The conductor coordinates all the separate parts into whatever holistic interpretation he/she is going for.
 
Try this experiment! Get your band mates together and clap 4/4, quarter notes at a moderate tempo for eight bars. Then have everyone close their eyes have absolute silence for 8 bars and clap on the downbeat of the 9th bar. Flam city right? If only there was someone to give us a visual cue!
 
Try this experiment! Get your band mates together and clap 4/4, quarter notes at a moderate tempo for eight bars. Then have everyone close their eyes have absolute silence for 8 bars and clap on the downbeat of the 9th bar. Flam city right? If only there was someone to give us a visual cue!

My bass player isn't allowed in any of the 9 bars in town.

My drummer thinks 4/4 can be reduced to one clap, or he has the clap, or something.
 
Last edited:
Try this experiment! Get your band mates together and clap 4/4, quarter notes at a moderate tempo for eight bars. Then have everyone close their eyes have absolute silence for 8 bars and clap on the downbeat of the 9th bar. Flam city right? If only there was someone to give us a visual cue!
That’s what drummers are for
 
they have basically memorized it; it's not like they're sight reading. The music is there as a reminder, which is helpful because the "songs" they're playing are a lot longer than any of those 40 cover songs.

tempo (which is rarely static), volume and timbre dynamics, etc. The sheet music gives general info, but that general info can be interpreted in lots of different ways. The conductor coordinates all the separate parts into whatever holistic interpretation he/she is going for.
How is having sheet music available any different than a cover band rock singer keeping song lyrics on an iPad? There have been several discussions here about how that is completely unprofessional, yet if you are a classical musician it’s ok?
As far as a particular interpretation by the conductor, that’s the same thing as a cover band playing a song and making small changes to “make it their own” or a guitar player improvising their own solos. (Which again, has been discussed here and the general consensus is that the songs should be played as close to the original so the dumb drunks in the bar are satisfied).

So why are all the things in rock which are considered a no-no all fine in the classical world?
For a bunch of “educated” musicians they don’t seem to be able to do anything without someone telling them how to do it.
 
How is having sheet music available any different than a cover band rock singer keeping song lyrics on an iPad? There have been several discussions here about how that is completely unprofessional, yet if you are a classical musician it’s ok?
As far as a particular interpretation by the conductor, that’s the same thing as a cover band playing a song and making small changes to “make it their own” or a guitar player improvising their own solos. (Which again, has been discussed here and the general consensus is that the songs should be played as close to the original so the dumb drunks in the bar are satisfied).

So why are all the things in rock which are considered a no-no all fine in the classical world?
For a bunch of “educated” musicians they don’t seem to be able to do anything without someone telling them how to do it.
I don't ever go to see cover bands, and so don't care if they use iPads for lyrics, etc., but I think the short answer to your general question is that the "classical world" is different than the "cover band world". They have different histories/backgrounds/contexts and people have different expectations. Why are professional wrestlers allowed to hit each other with chairs but olympic wrestlers aren't?
 
I don't ever go to see cover bands, and so don't care if they use iPads for lyrics, etc., but I think the short answer to your general question is that the "classical world" is different than the "cover band world". They have different histories/backgrounds/contexts and people have different expectations. Why are professional wrestlers allowed to hit each other with chairs but olympic wrestlers aren't?

1337345_1.jpg
 
I don't ever go to see cover bands, and so don't care if they use iPads for lyrics, etc., but I think the short answer to your general question is that the "classical world" is different than the "cover band world". They have different histories/backgrounds/contexts and people have different expectations. Why are professional wrestlers allowed to hit each other with chairs but olympic wrestlers aren't?
Well, one is real wrestling and one is fake...not the best analogy but I get your point. Lol
 
Yeah I know! If only the original drum score for the Ninth Symphony hadn't been lost in the Great Fire of London 1842.

lolololool
You didn’t read my first post above....this whole discussion started when I posted that I watched a YouTube vid of Dream Theater playing with an orchestra. My original question was why do they need a conductor to keep time when one of the best drummers in the world is doing it.....?
 
Back
Top