WTF: Assimilation Chronicles: iMac Edition. Resistance...

OGG

Master of the Meh
Well, my "free iMac" that was oh so close to pulling me over to the dark side, has decided to challenge my wherewithal.

Ok, so the HDD died, or so it appears. Fine, research like mad, weighing the options, finally succumbing to the advice of fruit hugging zealots, I order an SSD upgrade kit from OWC.

Great place for all things Mac, great service, fantastic tutorial videos... the price was pretty steep, but you know... apples.

Each kit is based on the exact year and manufacturing date of the individual machine. I ordered the kit after entering my serial number, which guarantees the proper items will comprise the kit.

While waiting for the kit to arrive, I watched the fantastic video they have which walks you through every step of the process to replace the drive. Very thorough, very well made. The kit comes with suction cups to remove the glass, a #10 Torx driver (which according to them, is the ONLY size needed), SSD, adapter cradle, and replacement thermal sensor.

So yesterday I set about replacing the HDD. The front glass came off just as it did in the video. I can't believe it's held in place with several tiny magnets. WTF?

Then I noticed that my LCD screen didn't look like the one in the video. In fact, they give you a little nylon pry bar to help pop the screen up out of the chassis, and the protruding tab that they used to place the tool behind in the video wasn't even there. After a thorough examination, I knew I would have to remove the front half of the clamshell case just to get to the LCD so I could remove it.

Sounds pretty easy... popped right off, almost. Ahh! So you have to unscrew and remove the little access plate on the bottom where the RAM chips are held? Ok, done, off with the front half (after disconnecting a tiny plug near the camera lens). Now I can get to the Torx screws that fasten the LCD to the chassis.

I grab my new #10 Torx driver and immediately realize it's not gonna work. No way. Luckily, I had my own set, and was back in business with a much smaller #7.

Got the LCD out, the guts look pretty much like those in the video. I pop all of the connections and remove the LCD entirely to have free access to the HDD. Here again, something doesn't jive (BTW, a few of the Internal Torx screws are #10... and some are #9 and some are #6). Fuckers.

First big issue: the thermal sensor is totally different. The one in my machine is just stuck to the HDD with adhesive, not at all like the built-in type it's "supposed" to have, and what necessitated the whole damn kit in the first place. WTF? Fuckers.

Anyway, the new sensor was useless, no biggie. Dropped in the new drive, re-atrached all seven thousand tiny connection plugs and put it all back together. Popped in my OS X El Cap Bootable USB thumb drive and fired it up.

No.

Hours upon hours of holding down various key combos at start up, resetting the SMC, clearing the VRAM, nothing worked. It simply couldn't "see" the new drive.

Some more research, possibly a bad SATA cable, maybe the Logic board itself.

Shits and giggles... plugged the original Mac HDD into an external drive bay and plugged it into my PC. loaded up Paragon, and bam! There it was... all three partions, fully intact and readable.

Fuck.

Hopefully it's just a bad SATA cable right? Should be an easy fix if so. No.

Fuck me runnin'! The amount of bullshit required just to get the old cable out was beyond ludicrous. Assholes. I can swap SATA cables in my PC without even shutting the machine off, and in less than 30 seconds. Not an apple though, no.

You have to completely disassemble this bastard just to get to it, and the liberal amount of stupid fucking tape from Hell they used to secure it to the inside of the case after running it through a thousand contortions along the crazy route from point A to point B... a distance of about 8" that requires an 18" cable to complete the journey. Motherfuckers.

Well, it's out. I have shit to do before I put this fruity fuckhead back together and see if it even works, but here are some horrifying images for you Mac lovers to enjoy in the meantime...

uploadfromtaptalk1463605417438.jpg

uploadfromtaptalk1463605428460.jpg

uploadfromtaptalk1463605443410.jpg

uploadfromtaptalk1463605453149.jpg
 
In fairness, you're going to run into that with any all-in-one machine. There's a trade off in compactness for accessibility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
Not surprising. Apple makes their machines with the intention that the users will never service them - only the 'genius' workers at an Apple store. They are not user update friendly - in fact they are user update unfriendly by design. Just by opening up you Mac your set off a secret beacon signal and now the Apple police are on to you and know your location and what you ate for breakfast.
 
I've only ever upgraded the memory in a Mac. While I can tear a PC down to its component parts and put it all back together I
d rather not mess with this and take mine (on the three occasions in 9 years I've had Apple computers fail) to LA Computer Company to fix.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
You have mistakenly assumed it is like a PC, but it's much more like a phone. Had you simply dropped it off at an Apple service center with 2 credit cards, you would have been up and running two or three weeks ago.

Macs are great, but I wouldn't pay for one with my own money.
 
In fairness, you're going to run into that with any all-in-one machine. There's a trade off in compactness for accessibility.

This.

FWIW, I replaced the hard drive in my previous iMac and I cracked the screen. Did it on the current one as well, and I was a little mire careful. Went quick and easy, no issues at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
But it's an apple, so it's really high quality, right, amirite? And if it doesn't work, it blinks at you so you can quickly identify where the problem lies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
I totally get the whole compactness and "stay out" build properties. I'm sure it's best that most consumers stay the Hell out of the Internals. I am no Mac expert, but learning quickly, and no computer... regardless of brand is going to intimidate me. Hell no. I built my first computer from parts in 1984 (Heathkit 9000) and have been a nerd ever since. I ain't skeered!

Sure, it's different, but a little knowledge and the right tools are all you need. Well, and patience. No way I'm paying some kid at the Genius bar a few hundred bucks to fix a 7 year old computer I got for free. I don't mind paying the premium for parts, but I will slay this beast on my own.
 
It has been a while since I had to have anything repaired on a Mac, but I sent a MacBook to Apple back in 2006 or so. It was having some issue (I don't remember what now) but it was a $200 fee and they not only fixed my issue, but they did a full diagnostic and ended up repairing a few other things that I didn't even realize were wrong. They also replaced the keyboard because it was one of the old white ones and it was very dirty. It is one of the reasons I like Macs. I work in IT fixing Windows shit all day long, I don't want to touch a computer when I am not working let alone fix one.
 
@OGG

I don't buy the compactness answer either. I have an HP All-in-One that the back comes off with regular Phillips screws and the hard drive and the memory and anything else is easily accessible. I upgraded that one from a Spinning Disk to an SSD in under 2 hours.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
@OGG

I don't buy the compactness answer either. I have an HP All-in-One that the back comes off with regular Phillips screws and the hard drive and the memory and anything else is easily accessible. I upgraded that one from a Spinning Disk to an SSD in under 2 hours.

It has nothing to do with compactness. It is to keep people out of it. Unlike PCs, Apple is responsible for the hardware and software so they don't like people opening them up and wrecking them. When I worked at UVA, I was sent to an Apple repair class. They are very easy to open up and upgrade if you have the right tools and have been trained.
 
I work in IT fixing Windows shit all day long, I don't want to touch a computer when I am not working let alone fix one.

I understand where you’re coming from. But Apple is making repairs much too hard with the 2015 models. Shit like soldering RAM directly to laptop mainboards and putting the iMac hard drive behind a screen that’s glued into place is ridiculous.
 
I understand where you’re coming from. But Apple is making repairs much too hard with the 2015 models. Shit like soldering RAM directly to laptop mainboards and putting the iMac hard drive behind a screen that’s glued into place is ridiculous.

Soldering RAM to the board is nothing new. Dell was doing that back in the early 2000s on some models. I got bit in the ass on that when I ordered a bunch for work and found you could add a stick of RAM, but the RAM in slot one wasn't coming out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
Soldering RAM to the board is nothing new. Dell was doing that back in the early 2000s on some models. I got bit in the ass on that when I ordered a bunch for work and found you could add a stick of RAM, but the RAM in slot one wasn't coming out.
My 8088-2 system had 640K soldered straight to the motherboard in an array of separate chips, not modules. Definitely not new.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OGG
My 8088-2 system had 640K soldered straight to the motherboard in an array of separate chips, not modules. Definitely not new.
Not new, but since the 386 RAM has almost always been a module that could easily be replaced in a socket, so IMO it's very stupid. And this is someone who hates using sockets in most other applications due to issue of connectivity from contamination on the pins in the manufacturing process causing yield issues. PC's have been modular for 30 years, and to do anything else is just a money grab to force you to buy another computer when either you want to upgrade something or a part goes tits up and needs to be replaced. And Apple is one of the few tech companies that makes a huge profit on their hardware.
 
Dear Apple Computer Company,

Fuck you, I win bitch!

No computer has ever beaten me, and your best effort was thwarted by my unyielding tenacity and overwhelming skill.

Suck it.

Sincerely,

OGG

uploadfromtaptalk1463799153977.jpg
 
Back
Top