I managed to avoid it until last year when some friends of mine hosted some Irish-y-ish movie night thing (I know, I know) and decided on Boondock Saints. These were grown-ups, mind you, who should have known better. The same people were also involved in my first trip to a Renaissance fair in over two decades. Hmm...
You just feel uncomfortable seeing a man in tights and make-up.
They did a documentary about the guy who wrote the film and his struggles with being a massive asshole in Hollywood while trying to produce the movie that's definitely worth watching:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0390336/
The words "have you ever seen Boondock Saints?" are the equivalent of wearing a "I'm Pretentious!" t-shirt.

Same thing goes for talking about how shit Boondock Saints is. Nobody's trying to give it an oscar, but if you're looking for an entertaining, action packed, 'guy' movie, it fits the bill quite well. If you're looking for a flower blossom that touches the soul and leaves you a changed man, a mere shell of what you were before that epitiome of viewing pleasure graced your previously virgin eyes with it's magnifacent glory, it's weaving of thematic imagery like a Longaburger basket, it's dramatic ,climatic, systematic, automatic, hyyyyydromatic scenes that cut to the heart like a suicide katana wielded by the Samurai God of Cinema ..well then you're a douche.![]()
Loved it. When the documentary about the making of your movie is better than your movie, you're in trouble.
Yeah. No, I'm not looking for any of those things.
Look man, you've reviewed four "guy" movies this weekend, and you've showed a preference for "pretty smart" over "exceedingly dumb" yourself. Boondock Saints is a movie for teenage boys, too... just teenage boys who are a little bit older and are into dropping terms like "existentialism", "commercialism", "hypocrisy", "mass media", "corruption", etc.
Fuck that shit. I liked seeing a toilet get dropped on a dude's head
I dub this "selective teenageism."
Boondock Saints is a piece of faux-edgy crap.
I make sure to bring it up on a regular basis. 
(warning... is quite violent and messed up)pulp fiction!!!!
I wouldn't necessarily consider either of these to be "guy movies," but I would consider them to be great fucking movies.the Matrix [...] the Big Lebowski.

My wife doesn't care for either. When Lebowski was in the theaters, my father took me to see it, my first viewing & his 2nd. My stepmother went with him to see it the first time; when invited again she said "No, you two go see your ugly men's movie."I wouldn't necessarily consider either of these to be "guy movies," but I would consider them to be great fucking movies.![]()
Most of the women I know who've seen the movie have liked it. It's definitely not a gender issue.My wife doesn't care for either. When Lebowski was in the theaters, my father took me to see it, my first viewing & his 2nd. My stepmother went with him to see it the first time; when invited again she said "No, you two go see your ugly men's movie."
As for a suggestion... track down a Korean movie called Old Boy.(warning... is quite violent and messed up)