Question: Here we have five red guitars

[Monson]

Yeah, I know, they are all expensive, but forget about the money for now or pretend it's on me, don't worry about it.

You can have one, so which one is it?

Gibson Custom Shop Super 400 CES Wine Red 1998

Gibson Custom Shop Super 400 CES Wine Red 1998 | Woodstock Guitars

The Gibson Super 400 has long been the flagship archtop of the Gibson lineup, embodying the pinnacle of craftsmanship, tone, and elegance. Introduced in 1934 as an evolution of Gibson’s previous high-end models, the Super 400 quickly became synonymous with jazz and big-band music, favored by...

www.woodstockguitars.dk

Gibson ES-330 Cherry 1960

Gibson ES-330 1960 | Woodstock Guitars

The Gibson ES-330 was introduced in 1959 as a fully hollow, thinline electric guitar, positioned as a more affordable alternative to the ES-335. Unlike the semi-hollow 335, the ES-330 lacks a center block, giving it a resonant, open tone with a woody warmth, perfect for blues, jazz, and rock...

www.woodstockguitars.dk

Fender Telecaster 1967 Candy Apple Red

Fender Telecaster 1967 Candy Apple Red | Woodstock Guitars

Here's a fantastic example of a late-'60s custom color Tele, finished in vibrant Candy Apple Red. The guitar shows plenty of wear, but the CAR finish still has deep metallic luster. This particular Telecaster features a non-factory installed, F-branded Bigsby tremolo. Neck is slightly chunkier...

www.woodstockguitars.dk

Fender Jazzmaster Candy Apple Red 1965

Fender Jazzmaster Candy Apple Red 1965 | Woodstock Guitars

Cool alert! 1965 Fender Jazzmaster in Candy Apple Red. Doesn't get much cooler, we think. All original except for the high E tuner replacement, with all the hallmarks of a well-loved gigging guitar. The neck is dated April 1965, and the potentiometers date to the 15th week of 1965, affirming its...

www.woodstockguitars.dk

Fender Jaguar Candy Apple Red 1965

Fender Jaguar Candy Apple Red 1965 | Woodstock Guitars

Introduced in 1962, the Jaguar was Fender's top-of-the-line model, designed to compete with Gibson’s higher-end guitars. Known for its shorter 24-inch scale length, unique floating tremolo system, and distinctive control layout, the Jaguar stood out with its versatile tone, favored by surf rock...

www.woodstockguitars.dk

 

[jrockbridge]

Red Red Wine

 

[Knox in Box]

It was close between 2/3, but I went with 2.

 

[jelloman]

330...if it were a 335, even better...

 

[Pine Apple Slim]

My fav is the Super 400....if its wasnt red. Too garish for that style of guitar.
I really like the 330 but it needs to loose the Bigsby.
Same goes for the Tele, except the BIgsby is even suckier.
Bigsby equipped guitars should not require a tension bar. If it does you put it on the wrong guitar IMO.
So it comes down to the Jag or JM as the top pick. Id have to play them to really decide which I preferred.
But just based on the looks that Jag is sexy so I'll go with it.

 

[tiger roach]

ES-330

 

[dodgechargerfan]

I went with the Jag as I don’t have anything even close to something like it.

 

[baimun]

330 and it’s not even close.

 

[Honkridge]

Bigsbys sound great but suck so...I'd take the Super 400 just to flip it. Not really into the offsets either. Pretty guitars though.

 

[Aahzz]

I don't really want any of them, but if forced to take one it'd be the 330 - and then I'd get the poop knife removed and replaced with a stop tail.

 

[Motorik]

I like all of them! I feel like if I went with my head I'd choose the Jazzmaster, but the one that is grabbing me the most is the 330. I'd really love to try it.
I'd really like to have a play on the Jag as well.

 

[bsman]

330 is all kinds of wonderful.

 

[Dew Knot Humps]

I rarely use guitar tremelo so for me it’s the 330 without a doubt.

 

[Gorgon90]

None of these are turning my head particularly so I'd look up the prices and take the one I'd get most for. Like the colour, just not guitars styles I'm into.

 

[Chicken Man]

If I was building a rig, I'd want one of the fenders. If I was adding to my current gear, it's going to be one of the hollow bodies because I've got a great Tele and a pretty crappy jazz box.