I posted the obvious answer over there
I generally buy instruments that sound the way I want them to begin with.
My one exception is my 1979 Gibson The Paul, which has a neck pickup I've never liked (T Top) so at some point once I shake loose some extra cash for it I'll be getting a new set for it.
I posted the obvious answer over there
i think everybody tries to do this. but then you get to the point where you want a little more a certain way, and the stockers just won't do the job. best guitar i've ever played is my PRS. but those pickups sucked.
honestly, i don't think you have to go much past Duncan and DiMarzio. and TV Jones for Gretsch pickups. just about everybody else is trying to recreate some sound they heard on a record 40 years ago and trying to remember now with their geriatric hearing.
Ha ha. I like the guy that says, "Ummm... Fender."
I decided years ago that it's so much easier just to stick with stock. If the guitar sounds good, buy it, love it, and keep it. YMMV
I came to a realization Saturday night (actually its been coming for a while but Saturday was the capper) as I was playing a gig through a fucking PEAVEY that most of this shit really doesn't matter that much as long as you buy decent stuff to start with and it's well maintained. And you learn how to play with good technique.
i dunno, i see pickups as personal preference. how the hell does PRS know that i like more vintage sounding pickups? so i took a great instrument and made it even better by putting in pups that sound the way i want them to. but there's still a limit on how much i'm going to spend.
my whole point of starting this thread was not to bash the replacement pickup industry. more to point out that when you ask what the "best ultra high end corksniffing pickup" is, that you're never going to get what you paid for. do some freaking research yourself.
Heh. I'm a bit surprised you're not banned yet for that one.
I'm just tired of people spending time money and energy on gear they'll never learn to use. I use to not really care since its their money and those are really the people supporting companies like Keeley and Xotic so that guys like me can have stuff we like but I guess the parade of students with $3k guitars has finally gotten to me.
i'm happy to say that i don't see $3k instruments come through at all. and if i did, i'd probably spend the first lesson asking them why they bought such an instrument and pointing out every last issue with it.
Unleashing your inner Ed Roman.....
i'm happy to say that i don't see $3k instruments come through at all. and if i did, i'd probably spend the first lesson asking them why they bought such an instrument and pointing out every last issue with it.
3k is chump change to some people.
We have a ton of adult students with money in our studio, especially since we teach the blues classes. They have no problem dropping $1200 on their first guitar and then $4000 on an es335. I'm not going to correct a customer like that. I just wish they'd ask for an opinion before they went to GC and bought the first thing they saw on the wall.