Which music legend going is going to hit you the hardest?

Dexter Inferno

Serious error
Having just seen the Paul McCartney SNL bit, I was just thinking. Of all the big artists that are still alive, he is the greatest. And for me that isn't debatable.

But was thinking....there are a few that when they're finally gone, that's going to be horrible when it happens.
Paul is the main one, then you have guys like Phil Collins (the drummer, mind you!) - and he's been in a horrible state health wise last few years.

Next up as for as idols for me would be Ian Anderson, Robert Fripp and guys like that.

But yeah, Paul is up there with Bowie for me. When he goes I know I'm going to be absolutely devastated.
There's the Beatles songs, but also Wings, Paul solo++ Has anyone else written that many hits??

I've done a few Beatles shows over here, and got to sing Eleanor Rigby a few years back, which is probably Paul's artistic highlight. Well, there's Band on The Run, Live And Let Die, Pipes of Peace and all sorts of stuff. And he shows up and does bass on a Stones track in his 80's. What a fucking monster of a man.
 
Ozzy. There are lots of celebrities I’ll miss, but I’ll cry when Ozzy goes. Sometimes I tear up just thinking about what he’s like now compared to what he was like when I saw him throwing buckets of water on the crowd and screaming profanity back in the nineties. I remember the year he broke out a water cannon. And the year he had water cannons built into the lighting rig. And the year he had a chair with a water cannon come down from the rafters and lift him up so he could really blast people. That man really loved punishing the people who paid for the good seats (not that he was ever the kind of bastard who charged excessive prices for the good seats).
 
I thought Paul was Dead :shrug:

Bowie was big for me. Given that 2 other Beatles have already died I don't think Paul will be such a hit like Bowie was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
It'll be rough when Kevin DuBrow goes. Gary Hudson's recent death was one for me. Stevie Wonder will probably devastate me when he goes. Willie's a good call, along with Dolly Parton.

FWIW, I wouldn't have named a single one of those Paul songs as his peak. Not looking for a flight, it's just evidence of the depth of his catalog.
 
Obviously for me, Donovan will hit me hard. Graham Nash is another. I am happy to have seen both of them in concert in recent years.

For me, Ringo is the remaining Beatle that will hit hard. I find myself loving his solo stuff that I hear on the Sirius Beatles channel. Photograph is a song that grabs me every time. His public persona is uplifting to me.
 
Dion DiMucci is the first that springs to mind for me, because I think that he's the last of the original fifties rock 'n' roll really big stars. (Wanda Jackson's still around too, and she's great, but Dion is the much bigger name.)

Stevie Wonder
Willie Nelson
Debbie Harry
 
At this point John Prine hit me the hardest.
But idk, at this point Ive seen so many greats go I worry that Id probably just be numb rather than consider my own mortality.
 
Billy Gibbons, Bonnie Raitt, Brian Setzer (hopefully, Setzer will kick his current health issues and have several more years)

And of course the elephant in the room: Keith Richards. He seems to be immortal, but we all know he is on borrowed time.
 
Eddie Van Halen hit very hard. Lynyrd Skynyrd’s plane crash was hard. Dusty Hill, Lemmy, and Lowell George were very sad for me.

There really isn’t anyone else who’s currently alive I feel is going to shake me much at all.
 
the two that are most likely to make me cry will be Elton and Steve Miller.

edit: Carole King and James Taylor are on that list also.
 
Last edited:
Yes Paul's stand-in is going to be devastating when he leaves us. That guy is more talented than the original and that isn't debatable for me.

Billy will be huge, as will be Ozzy.

Worst until now was Cornell. I literally cried more for him than some relatives.
 
I was devastated when Clarence passed so Springsteen will be a big one.

Ian Hunter will be a big one too.

I'll be bummed when Elton goes. Keith and Mick too.


Mike Campbell
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
The day I found out Prince had died, I was arriving at a client's office and I just sat in my car for probably 20 minutes... in shock. Re-read the news and played his songs from the soundtrack of my life the rest of the week. I think he died on a Tuesday, and the next day I texted the members of my band and gave them 3 Prince songs to learn for our Saturday gig.

While we were were playing that weekend, I could see a TV in the bar area from the stage... we just started playing "Kiss" and I noticed that SNL was paying tribute to Prince performing... so I'm singing his song and I see Prince's face in the TV looking back at me. The hair stood up on the back of my neck, but then it kind of washed over me... he isn't with us anymore... but his music will remain as the soundtrack of my life as long as I'm here.

Ironically though, the song I want played at my funeral is the Chris Cornell version of "Nothing Compares to You". I can't think of a song that better combines Prince's songwriting with my love for hard rock, and in an amusing wink how much I love covers that take the baton and bring something fresh and new. I feel like that is something we can all strive to do in our lives... take what our upbringing, our circumstances, or our friends and loved ones around us and carry that to someplace new and hopefully touch people's hearts along the way. :baimun:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
Cornell unexpectedly hit me the hardest.

I clearly remember when Lennon was killed. That was a big one, but at 8 yrs old I didn't fully understand every level. I knew that I loved John's music in and out of the Beatles, I knew that he was a man that spoke to peace and love, I knew he had a son a few years younger than me that lost his dad.

SRV was a big one, was at Five Towns College and classes were just starting. Stop at shop for breakfast and saw the paper...devastating. I had just seen him in July and he almost ran over me w/ his scooter. Killer show, otherworldly musician.

Freddie hit really hard too. My dad only liked a few hits, but Queen grabbed me early and never let up. The next evolution of a band like the Beatles. And that voice, one of the best ever.

Remember feeling sad about Cobain. Wasn't a fan at the time, but you knew something had to be really wrong for how he went out.

George was hard, but we were recovering from a miscarriage that summer and then 9/11...he got lost in our and then the whole world turning upside down. I grieved more a bit later. But the Beatles are that one band, that group/collective/artist that I don't hesitate to call my favorite. That we've had Paul and Ringo for so long and that they're still out there playing and creating, it's a blessing.

LeRoi Moore from Dave Matthews Band, my second favorite sax player after Coltrane. Not saying there were on the same level as players, but the way their playing caught and kept my attention, their expressiveness...they touch me in a very similar manner. He is one of my favorite musicians, period. I wish I'd gotten to see him more, but being new parents to two boys in the 2000s made concerts tough, and stadium shows (which they were almost exclusively doing) haven't been my jam for decades (if they ever were). I still love the band, but his absence is tough to miss if you know the music, what it was, and its potential were Roi still around.

Juan Nelson from the Innocent Criminals was another particularly rough one. Ben is one of my favorite artists, but it was with the IC that he reached the highest levels. The core of that for me was Juan. He's the guy that made me realize I shoulda taken up bass. I've bought two and still have one, haven't developed any real chops on it, but the sound and feel (musically) of the bass really (finally?) grabbed by the collar and shook me with Burn to Shine and Live from Mars.

Jeff Beck was a shock because he wasn't ill as far as I knew, so many of his peers that passed have been sick, had decades of alcohol and drug abuse, etc. That he had bacterial meningitis and succumbed to it as quickly as folks can in a worst case scenario, almost unfathomable...

Zakir Hussain was also a shock given that he passed from a longterm degenerative illness, but I had just seen him with Shakti in 2023. He was amazing, an ageless wonder of a musician.

And the list is too long to even just list. The loss of artists that we love is clearly profound on many levels, especially when they are truly unique artists. A voice is extinguished and we'll never hear anything new from it.

The biggest folks that have passed in the last decade and those who we might expect to pass within the next decade...the vast majority are at or past the "average" life span. They have lived full lives, they have achieved greatness, created some of my favorite art.

And that's part of what hit so hard about Cornell, I came to realize. Despite his 8 yr older age difference, he was essentially a contemporary, an influence, someone I aspired to be like or the type of artist I'd hope to work with. Add that to the significance of his music and much from the 90s on me and in my life, it was a physical and mental a gut punch as I'd felt in the passing of an artist.

Don't get me wrong, I will have a profound sadness if I'm still around when either of the Pauls, Stevie Wonder, Young, Gabriel, the guys in the Police, May, and (again) far too many others to list. But, as with Garth Hudson's recent passing, my sadness was overtaken by the joy of thinking about and then listening to the music he'd created. He had 87 years doing what he loved and sharing with the rest of us. I hope I'm lucky enough to get another 34 years to enjoy what all of my favorite artists have given me.
 
Eddie Van Halen hit very hard.....

I think the only reason that Eddie didn't hit me as hard, despite being a huge fan.... When he went through that really rough drinking binge and almost looked homeless on stage, I kinda prepped myself that we were going to lose him. I think he had the cancer diagnosis and then thought "Oh... now we're really going to lose him..." but he got healthier, got a new haircut, new teeth... and then they did the later tour... but to me it felt like "Okay, any one of us could be gone at any minute... so we're going to squeeze a few more shows out." and then he was gone.

I was extremely sad, but was more mentally prepared than when Prince's passing ripped the rug out from underneath me. :cry:
 
Prince, I can't believe I forgot him...

Massive shock because I had always heard and thought he was as clean as they came. I believe he humble bragged on occasion that he avoided alcohol and drugs because they clouded his mind, which he wasn't having. He wanted to be fully present in the creation of his music. I remember seeing all his early videos on MTV, but When Doves Cry came out...that was something else. I don't think anyone else was blending r&b and rock like Prince. And I remember going to see the film with my late sister and her boyfriend...it was so cool seeing real musicians playing musicians in a movie. I hadn't started playing guitar yet, but I know the film was a catalyst. In the fall of 1984 I started taking "playing" guitar, lessons started shortly after, and we off to the middling amateur races.

Petty was also a shock a year later. His and Prince's passing were what really open my eyes to the opioid problem in this country. It wasn't something my family, friends, community, or colleagues were dealing with...we were all lucky in that regard. But it reminded of of when Christopher Reeve got thrown from his horse...he was Superman, how could something like this stop him? How could shitty little fentanyl take out these powerhouses. Of course, they're all just people, but they were objectively special people.

Prince's and Petty's music spent a significant amount of time just being music I enjoyed, but then at some point their overall and continued impact on me became apparent. Some many incredible songs, not just the hits, but fuck me if so many of the hits weren't better than 90-95% of the rest of music coming out. Their influence, impact, power, and more was so significant. I got pissed at the medical community, specifically Petty's doctors, as you can't give opioids to a recovering addict, which Tom was. Then I was angry at Tom, because he shoulda known to avoid this shit too. But I can't speak to the pain he was in and don't think he or anyone should suffer.

The thing with these guys and Cornell, was that I think they still had some good or even great music left in them. Cornell was still writing and regularly releasing new music. And despite being older and in that phase of a career where folks want to go to a greatest hits show, Tom and Prince were still writing and playing new tunes for fans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tig
Back
Top